From: Jonathan Davis (jonathan@limbicnutrition.com)
Date: Tue Jun 25 2002 - 07:34:28 MDT
A Vigorous Skeptic of Everything but Fact
By DINITIA SMITH
http://www.nytimes.com/2002/06/19/arts/television/19SKEP.html?pagewanted=pri
nt&position=top
hese are some of the things that Paul Kurtz, chairman of the Committee for
the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal and publisher of
the magazine Skeptical Inquirer, does not believe in: parapsychology,
holistic cures for animal illnesses, the universal effectiveness of
chiropractic, extraterrestrial beings, alternative medicine, Bigfoot and
organized religion.
For 35 years Mr. Kurtz has kept up a drumbeat of opposition to all kinds of
this nonsense, as he calls it. And now he is turning his attention to the
proliferation of the paranormal in movies and on television. Although movies
are obviously fiction, Mr. Kurtz said, their power and influence are
enormous. Meanwhile some television shows are presenting extraterrestrial
conversations as a real thing.
"The television networks are selling communication with the dead with
abandon," Mr. Kurtz complained as he sat in the headquarters of the Center
for Inquiry in Amherst, N.Y., near Buffalo, the secular humanist
organization that is the umbrella group for all his interests. Mr. Kurtz
pointed to John Edward's show, "Crossing Over," and to James Van Praagh and
George Anderson, mediums who also appear regularly on television claiming to
talk to the dead.
Then "there are the increasing number of scenes in soap operas that are set
in heaven," Mr. Kurtz said, adding that movies are also gross offenders. For
instance, on Aug. 2, Touchstone is scheduled to release "Signs," starring
Mel Gibson, about the mysterious appearance of crop circles on a family
farm. Another example is "The Mothman Prophecies" with Richard Gere,
released in January, in which the characters are terrified by an
otherworldly creature in the form of a giant moth.
To monitor these trends his investigating committee, which its members call
Csicop (pronounced SY-cop), has opened a National Media Center on Hollywood
Boulevard in Los Angeles. And tomorrow Mr. Kurtz and some 400 other skeptics
from around the world are to convene in Los Angeles at the World Skeptics
Congress at the Hilton Burbank Airport and Convention Center to discuss
these and other concerns.
"We are all concerned with this media distortion," he said. "We consider
this area of pseudoscience to be critical."
"We are the heroic defenders of science and reason," said Mr. Kurtz, 76, an
emeritus professor of philosophy at the State University of New York at
Buffalo and author or editor of 35 books, including the "Secular Humanist
Manifesto II." And he is not above a touch of humor in his crusade.
The March-April issue of the Skeptical Inquirer, for instance, gave a
special "Foot in Mouth Disease Award" to the Rev. Jerry Falwell for holding
pagans, abortionists and feminists partly responsible for the Sept. 11
terrorist attacks. And to another minister, Jack Brock, and the Christ
Community Church of Alamogordo, N.M., the magazine gave a Pagan Pride Award
for sponsoring "a Harry Potter book burning."
"Our kind of saints are magicians and comedians," Mr. Kurtz said. "They show
by sleight of hand how you can deceive." Magicians often perform at his
group's conventions.
Mr. Kurtz's operations have an annual budget of $11 million. The center has
small branches in Los Angeles and Montclair, N.J., and has about 40
employees overall. There are affiliated groups in Russia, France, Peru,
Germany, Africa and other locations.
In an effort to dispel the notion that paranormal powers exist and to debunk
its other targets, like organized religion, Mr. Kurtz publishes magazines
and newsletters, including The Skeptical Inquirer, which Mr. Kurtz said had
a circulation of about 50,000. Other magazines include Free Inquiry, The
Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine, Scientific Review of Mental
Health Practice and a few others. Mr. Kurtz also operates a publishing
house, Prometheus Books, which brings out about 100 books a year. In
addition the center sponsors a student organization, the Campus Freethought
Alliance, and S.O.S. (for Save Ourselves), a secular alternative to
Alcoholics Anonymous. "You don't need a higher spiritual power to get rid of
alcohol addiction," he said.
The struggle against organized religion is lonely. Religion exerts a tyranny
over society, he said, and for an American politician "the worst crime is to
be an agnostic." In France, François Mitterrand and former Prime Minister
Lionel Jospin reported they were agnostics. "They could not get away with
that here."
He added: "Years ago you never met anyone who believed in Satan. Now it's
common." By his count there are "1,350 cults and sects in the United States,
from the Church of Scientology to Hasidic Judaism," he said, speaking of
offshoots of mainstream religions.
Still Mr. Kurtz insists he is not anti-religion. "Some of my best friends
are Christians," he said with a twinkle in his eye.
Not only does mainstream religion constitute a tyranny, but beliefs like
"Astrology and U.F.O.-ology have become major religions of our day," he
said.
"Among our strongest supporters are astronomers, because they are confused
with astrologers and U.F.O.-ologists and Scientologists." The International
Astronomical Union, which names newly discovered bodies in the skies, have
named asteroid No. 6,629 Kurtz for him.
The bland, modernist headquarters of the center is a virtual temple to
reason. In the main reading room is a bust of Mr. Kurtz's great hero,
Charles Darwin, whose theories of natural selection as the basis of
evolution run counter to some conservative Christians' belief system. Every
Feb. 12 the center celebrates his birthday with lectures, films and a
birthday cake.
On the walls are paintings to illustrate some of the center's precepts. One,
called "The Ascent of Reason," shows the figures of Hypatia, Democritus,
Aristotle, Socrates, Epicurus and Protagoras, who said, "Man is the measure
of all things." Another, "Prometheus Bound," is a homage to Prometheus, who
stole fire from the gods and bequeathed it to humankind and taught humans
arts and sciences. There is also a strange painting based on "The Last
Supper," with Susan B. Anthony, Sidney Hook, Charles Darwin, Leonardo da
Vinci, Bertrand Russell, Voltaire and other atheists and humanists seated
around the table instead of the apostles.
In addition there is a picture of Mr. Kurtz's friend the comedian Steve
Allen. Over the years Prometheus published 15 of Mr. Allen's books,
including "Steve Allen on the Bible, Religion and Morality."
Another room at the center is the Academy of Humanism, with busts of
Aristotle, Socrates and great humanists. The basement holds the center's
collection of some 35,000 books and pamphlets relating to evolution, secular
humanism, atheism and skepticism.
Mr. Kurtz, who was born in Newark, the son of a businessman, was left-wing
in his youth, he said. But serving in the Army in World War II taught him
the dangers of ideology. He entered the Dachau and Buchenwald camps after
they were liberated. He also became disillusioned with Communism when he
encountered Russian slave laborers who had been taken to Germany forcibly
and refused to return to the Soviet Union at the end of the war.
As an undergraduate at New York University in the 1940's Mr. Kurtz came
under the influence of the philosopher Sidney Hook and pragmatism. He wrote
his Ph.D. thesis at Columbia University on value theory, on whether there
can be a science of ethics. He is married to Claudine Vial, a retired French
teacher. They have four children, including Jonathan, 33, a vice president
of Prometheus Books.
Mr. Kurtz founded the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims
of the Paranormal when he was teaching at Buffalo in the 1970's. He said he
had noticed that students were suddenly saying that they believed in
astrology, U.F.O.'s and other mystical systems. In 1973 he published "The
Humanist Manifesto II." It set forth his philosophy of pragmatic skepticism,
which he saw as a continuation of John Dewey's philosophy of pragmatism.
Today one of Mr. Kurtz's biggest challenges, in addition to the
proliferation of people talking to the dead in movies and on television, is
Islam. "Islam is a great religion, a great culture," he said. "It
contributed to the preservation of science in the 8th, 9th and 10th
centuries." But there is a need for a scientific analysis of Islam's claims,
such as the belief of some Muslims that religious martyrs are greeted by 72
virgins in Paradise.
"There is a rich tradition of inquiry into Islam dating back to the
19th-century French and German scholarly critiques," Mr. Kurtz said. "There
are many versions of the Koran. We don't know if we have the authentic one.
Muhammad never wrote anything down. Some of it was written 150 years later."
As in the Bible, the prophet's words in the Koran and the Hadith, his
collected sayings, were recorded by followers.
"Islam desperately needs a Protestant-like Reformation," he continued. The
Islamic system is the product of "a nomadic, agrarian society, pre-modern
and pre-urban, which they are trying to apply to the contemporary world."
Mr. Kurtz is well aware of the dangers of criticizing Islam. "Anything
critical of Islam, you can get a fatwa," he said. But no matter, he said.
"My main interest is defending humanism as an alternative morality, of
happiness here and now, of autonomy and individual freedom and dignity, and
of the value of the exuberance of this life."
He concluded, "Islam and Judaism and Christianity are false."
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Wed Sep 25 2002 - 13:28:47 MDT